Introduction to epidemiological delays

Nowcasting and forecasting of infectious disease dynamics

Epidemiological delay

Time between two epidemiological events

Epidemiological events: disease progression

  • infection
  • symptom onset
  • becoming infectious
  • hospital admission
  • death

Epidemiological events: recovery

  • pathogen clearance
  • symptoms clearance
  • end of infectiousness
  • discharge from hospital

Epidemiological events: control

  • quarantine
  • isolation
  • treatment

Epidemiological events: reporting

  • specimen taken
  • report added to database

Some delays have names

infection to symptom onset

Incubation period

Some delays have names

infection to becoming infectious

Latent period

Some delays have names

becoming infectious to end of infectiousness

Infectious period

Some delays have names

hospital admission to discharge

Length of stay

Some delays have names

symptom onset (person A) to symptom onset (person B, infected by A)

Serial interval

Some delays have names

infection (person A) to infection (person B, infected by A)

Generation interval

Why do we want to know these?

Key parameters in mathematical models

Ferguson et al., 2020

Key parameters in mathematical models

Ward et al., 2020

Key elements of infectious disease epidemiology

Nishiura et al., 2007

Why do we want to know these?

  • Key elements of infectious disease epidemiology

  • Intricate relationship with nowcasting/forecasting

Quantifying delays

  • Epidemiological delays are variable between individuals

  • We can capture their variability using probability distributions

What is a probability distribution?

  • Mathematical way to describe variability in delays

  • Shows how likely different delay values are

  • Common examples for delays:

    • Log-normal: right-skewed, good for incubation periods
    • Gamma: flexible shape, alternative for delays

Warning: Two levels of uncertainty

  • Probability distributions characterise variability in the delays between individuals
  • Parameters of the probability distribution can be uncertain

\[ \alpha \sim \mathrm{Normal}(mean = 5, sd = 0.1) \\ \beta \sim \mathrm{Normal}(mean = 1, sd = 0.1) \\ \]

Showing probability density functions of lognormal distributions with shape \(\alpha\) and rate \(\beta\).

Statistical inference for delays

  • We observe delay data but don’t know true distribution parameters

  • Need to estimate parameters from incomplete, noisy data

  • Bayesian approach: prior knowledge + observed data → posterior estimates

Stan for delay estimation

  • Statistical software for Bayesian inference

  • We specify: data structure, parameters to estimate, model relationships

  • Stan returns parameter estimates with proper uncertainty quantification

Your Turn

  • Simulate epidemiological delays
  • Estimate parameters of a delay distribution

Return to the session